
LC
Lyuhao Chen, Xi Cheng, Yanming Kang, Ruiyan Zhu, Ke Liu, Rakesh Chowdary Machineni, Yulang Fei, Brian Zhu, Daniel Jin, Binze Cai, Zheng Qi, Neeraj Parihar, Zhoutian Xu, Oliver Gao
· 1 min read
ResearcharXiv cs.AI
SheetMind: Actions Set Accuracy, Agents Set the Failure Mode
arXiv:2506.12339v3 Announce Type: replace-cross
Abstract: Spreadsheet agents are converging on elaborate multi-agent designs, yet it is unclear how much of their performance comes from the agents rather than from the action interface they share. We answer this with SheetMind, a Manager-Action-Reflection framework, in a controlled study over all 221 tasks of the SheetCopilot Benchmark: five architectural variants, four backbones, exact McNemar tests on paired outcomes, and a checker reproducing the official chart and pivot comparisons. Replacing the high-level action API with primitive cell operations costs 47.1 points (p < 0.0001) and leaves the agent below a do-nothing baseline, whereas both extra agents together are worth 3.2 points: the Reflection Agent adds +4.5 (p = 0.013), the Manager +1.4 (p = 0.68). Decomposition instead changes how the system fails, cutting silently wrong outputs from 33% to 25% of tasks (p = 0.010). Capability saturates: GPT-5 and the five-times-cheaper GPT-5-mini are not significantly different (61.1% vs. 58.4%, p = 0.15), while GPT-3.5 loses 16.3 points and fails differently. A reflector must judge the step it just took, not the subtask. SheetMind reaches 61.1% Pass@1 with GPT-5 on the full SCB-221, against a do-nothing baseline of 9.0%. Accuracy comes from the operations an agent can name; the agents decide how it fails.
Original source
This story was published by arXiv cs.AI and written by Lyuhao Chen, Xi Cheng, Yanming Kang, Ruiyan Zhu, Ke Liu, Rakesh Chowdary Machineni, Yulang Fei, Brian Zhu, Daniel Jin, Binze Cai, Zheng Qi, Neeraj Parihar, Zhoutian Xu, Oliver Gao. SyncAI.news shows a preview; the complete article is on the publisher's site.
Read the full story on arxiv.org


